
Intro
In my Investigator Expansion Review for the Drowned City box, I claimed that one of the nicest features of the box for brand new players is how it offers two simple investigators that work out of the box even on the most limited of card pools. Lucius Galloway and Michael McGlen together form the typical power couple of one investigator that provides the clue finding capabilities to advance the act and one investigator that brings the hurt to keep the Mythos in check. To put my money time where my mouth is I figured it would be useful to double check how valid that claim of mine is and actually go ahead and build those decks with nothing but cards from the Core and the Drowned City Investigator Box. Hell, if this looks good, i might even end up playing this on my blind playthrough of the new campaign once it releases.
Since this article series is addressed at newer players, i will also go into a bit more detail about some of the underlying concepts of the game, building a deck and card choices than usual.
Lucius Galloway
As the seeker of the team, Lucius’ job is to gather clues. To comfortably beat the typical scenario in a two-player environment, we’d want to shoot for 2 clues per turn discovered as a baseline. Helping with that will be his investigator ability which gains us a clue as long as we are able to oversucceed evasion tests against enemies. This won’t be possible every turn because we don’t expect to have an enemy around permanently, but it still will do a bit of work for us. Access to both the Seeker and the Rogue cardpool will help us develop both sides of Lucius, strengthening both our ability to investigate using our intellect and our ability to keep enemies in check (and get handouts along the way) with our agility.
Lucius big achilles heel is his low sanity of 6 coupled with a low willpower of only 2 which makes him very vulnerable to treacheries that deal horror if you can’t pass a willpower test. This type of treachery is a mainstay in encounter decks throughout the game and very common. To make matters worse, his signature weakness also deals horror that won’t really be avoidable and also shuffles back so you can expect to see it multiple times per scenario. The deck will have to address this problem or otherwise we risk dying to horror mid-scenario… and the mental trauma from that will only make things worse in the scenarios after that.
At Level 0
To get the discussion going, here’s a proposal for how a level 0 deck for Lucius on a tightly limited card pool would look like:

We devote both of our handslots to our primary job, investigating locations for clues.
Flashlight: Cheap and reliable, offers the equivalent (or better) of a +2 to the test. Just an all around solid card that does the job.
Magnifying Glass: Even cheaper and more reliable, it offers a +1 that doesn’t run out of charges. Play this once and now you investigate at 5. You might even play the second and can ride them for the rest of the scenario, their bonus does indeed stack.
Forensic Kit: Using your agility instead of intellect for your investigation basically gives you +1 to your test, but do note that Mag Glass won’t be helping you then. And neither do Milan, Perception or Deduction (Manual Dexterity will, though!). It is still worth playing for us however, as the horror heal on Forensic Kit will be our main defense against horror inflicted by treacheries and our own weakness. Consider not spending the uses on this before you actually have horror to heal and an evaded enemy on your location. Also be aware that you don’t have to use agility here. If you have a bunch of +1 intellect bonuses stacked on the board already, you can just test intellect and make use of those bonuses.
Our ally is very strong.
Dr. Milan Christopher: He’s basically holding another Mag Glass for us, for a global +1 intellect bonus that supports our main job. He also hands out resources. While he is not cheap himself, he will pay off rather quick and help us gain the resources needed for our assets and events. Milan also soaks one point of horror for us without being defeated which is more relevant than one would think, especially when the whole sanity situation is already on a razor’s edge like it is with Lucius.
Quick aside on the optional list of taboos: Milan is strong enough to land a spot on the so-called taboo list, where his text got changed to rein him in a bit. When using taboo, which is completely optional, Milan exhausts on gaining a resource, meaning you can no longer gain two or more resources from him per turn. As a new player, do not worry about this. At all. The changes on the list are made under the assumption of full card pools and the player power that comes with it. There is no reason to worry about gaining a handful extra resources with Milan while still on a fledgling collection. Those that play with taboo do instead play events that gain 5 resources in one action and other wild things to make up for it that you don’t have access to yet. Just play stuff as printed, the game is difficult enough. Worry about the optional stuff once you feel like you need extra challenge. And if the decision then is to still ignore taboo, that’s perfectly okay as well.
For the accessory slot, we have elaborate plans for our upgrade path where we will sink a considerable amount of XP here, but for now all we have is …
Dial of Ancients: This thing is fairly easy for Lucius to research, as long as he can draw it early enough. Four evasions at his location is something he can do himself. You may consider keeping one enemy around for longer to get this done and gain access to the upgraded versions that actually do a thing.
We actually have something for the arcane slots, too. Well, kind of.
Uncanny Specimen: Mostly acts as glue and filler for our deck, a fast card that draws us another card so we get through our deck quicker and find the stuff we are actually looking for. We have to pay a resource for the privilege, but the Specimen’s ability to bend a test result in our favor makes this worthwhile.
Next up is a range of assets that don’t take up a limited slot. You can play all of these to the board at the same time and stack all of their effects, so there won’t be any “dead” cards clogging up your hand. These assets help you pass tests and/or provide a steady stream of cards to play or commit.
Pickpocketing: A card per turn, as long as you have enemies around to evade. One of Lucius strengths is that he doesn’t lose tempo when evading enemies because he can still get a clue out of it. Pickpocketing builds on this strength to the point where you will actively want to keep an enemy around to bully every turn.
String Along: String Along is even better than Pickpocketing for us. While it is more expensive and also needs to exhaust before we know if we past the test, it also gives a +1 to that test, making that crucial oversuccess for a clue more likely. It also doesn’t disengage the enemy, which sounds like a drawback but is actually a good thing when your plan involves dragging an enemy around with you to exploit over and over.
Hyperawareness: While our resource situation is not great, an early Milan can sometimes lead to situations where you have some to spare and want an outlet. Hyperawareness is that outlet, allowing us to bolster both our intellect and agility with cash. That being said, if you find yourself short on money when you draw it, this is one you might just want to commit for its icons.
Artistic Inspiration: It’s a way to gain +1 to your tests after knowing the result, turning barely-fails into barely-passes or regular successes into oversuccesses. Your card draw is strong enough to support feeding into the card. Note that it does stack with Book of Verse. If you get those two cards together you will find that you are suddenly able to pass some tests you had no business to pass before and that your investigator ability becomes very consistent.
Book of Verse: Your signature asset does the same thing that Artistic Inspiration does, except it’s just straight up better. It doesn’t require a discard to recharge, instead just a clue discovery… which is our main plan anyways. Book of Verse will even draw the occasional card, further stacking with what we are getting from our evasion based card draw.
This list is heavy on assets, so the event section is predictably short.
Emergency Cache: One of the greatest failings of the Core Set is that it doesn’t give a resource event to Rogue. Drowned City doesn’t do so either, so this is what we have to work with. It does the job, i suppose. Only having a pair of Caches for resource events means that getting an early Milan Christopher on the board is going to make a huge difference for us.
Backstab: These are ways for Lucius to weaponize his agility into some hefty spike damage. Usually, we’ll want to rely on Michael to keep Lucius safe and handle emergencies through evasion. But having the option to defeat an enemy on our own is still going to be very useful. If nothing else, these can be used to help Michael defeat some huge boss enemy to finish a scenario. Since we are going into the Drowned City campaign blind, we also include these to prepare ourselves for any situations where the investigators get forcibly separated, a situation that comes up every now and then.
Finally, we round out the whole thing with a good amount of skills. The nice thing about skills is that they are free, so having a chunk of them in the list does its part towards relieving our resource situation as well.
Deduction: A card for a clue is a very classic trade for seekers to make to accelerate their gameplan. And with all the card draw in the deck, it’s a small price indeed.
Perception: These make sure your Deductions don’t fail. They also just generically bolster your investigations while also drawing you a card, accelerating you towards the assets that give you more lasting bonuses.
Manual Dexterity: Same deal as with Perception, these help your tests while churning towards your important assets. For Lucius specifically, these also help a lot with getting that oversuccess on the evasion test that nets him a clue.
Unexpected Courage: While these can pretty much bolster any test you face, i’d advise you to be a bit precious about using them. With Lucius willpower being as low as it is, you will eventually run into a situation where you need to pass a willpower test, but struggle with it. Most of the tests come at a difficulty of 3, so Courage taking you from 2 to 4 won’t even be good enough to really be comfortable. However, with either Artistic Inspiration, Book of Verse or ideally both on the table, you have a real fighting chance once you throw in a Courage. You have a very limited amount of tries for this trick however and you may want to carefully consider tossing your Courage into a random investigate or evasion test now when it could possibly be used to free yourself from a Frozen in Fear a couple turns later.
Options at level 0
Here are some suggestions for tweaks to the list:
-1 Dial of Ancients: As you will see with the leveled up list in a moment, my list dips rather heavily into the accessory slot and even runs a Relic Hunter. If that is not up to your taste, then Dial of Ancients is the first thing to lose here as you will want a much better accessory than any of the upgraded Dials if you only have one slot.
-1 Hyperawareness, +1 Artistic Inspiration: The way i laid out the slotless assets, you can just play everything to the board and have everything stack with each other. There is an argument to be made that Inspiration is good enough that you want a second copy. Hyperawareness would be the card to cut for it.
-2 Backstab: Lucius doesn’t need to fight. He has innate enemy handling through his high evasion and we are planning on adding a focused main fighter to the team. So these are not strictly necessary and removing them would actually help a bit with our resources too as they are quite expensive at 3 resources.
+2 Bum’s Rush: A solid alternative to Backstab. While it doesn’t have the utility of allowing Lucius to help with nuking a boss enemy, it does have that option of shoving something into a connecting location which does add something that neither Lucius nor Michael would be able to do. It’s also a bit cheaper to play than Backstab.
+2 Guts: The other great option i see for this deck. I am not particularly big on playing Guts in investigators with 2 or less willpower, but the presence of Artistic Inspiration and Book of Verse does make it look more appealing. You could also use it to brute force a willpower test by committing both Guts and Unexpected Courage.
Especially if you are worried about willpower treacheries (a fair thing to worry about!), then removing a Hyperawareness and the Backstabs for another copy of Artistic Inspiration and a pair of Guts could really help you in that regard!
Upgrading
When thinking about how to upgrade my deck, i like to create a deck of about 20-25XP based on the level 0 deck. This is about the amount of XP that you can reliably expect to get on the blind play of a new campaign. The maximum amounts of XP will usually go significantly higher, but remember that especially on the first playthrough you may very well fail scenarios completely or go down a campaign path that leads nowhere productive. Recent campaigns also have a tendency of letting you play fewer than the usual eight scenarios one would expect from old campaigns. So formulating big plans based on 40XP aren’t terribly useful before you know if that’s even achievable. Aim lower and instead work out the priority of those upgrades and how you could see the deck evolve.
Again, i will start by showing you the decklist, then I’ll explain what happened there:

So, let’s get the big thing about this list out of the way first: I am throwing a whopping 15xp at the accessory slot here. That’s three quarters of the first 20xp we earn.
+1 Antikythera – 5XP: This is probably the best thing that Lucius can have in his accessory slot, even at a full cardpool. Just for succeeding a test per turn, it keeps throwing value at you in the form of cards, resources, clues or even actions. A fantastic card on its own, Lucius takes it to the next level with his Book of Verse which not only covers the “succeed by 0” case to complement it, but also allows shifting the test result so you pretty much always get to pick between either getting the cards/resources or the clue. Thanks to Antikythera, it’s very common to collect 2 clues just for evading an enemy: 1 from Lucius ability, one from the accessory. Note: Don’t get caught up in the extra action for a +5 success, the real juice of this card lies in consistently getting one of the lower two rewards turn after turn after turn. Overcommitting cards to test 9 vs 2 just for a shot at the +5 reward is not worth it. Save the commits and build up the value slowly and steadily.
+1 Signs of Revelation – 4XP: This upgrade for the Dial allows investigating as a free action with tests being easier while an enemy is at Lucius location. This further plays into our theme of exploiting enemies for clues.
+1 Elder Sign Amulet – 3XP: 4 extra points of sanity to keep our weakness to horror in check. It’s not pretty, but it works.
+1 Relic Hunter – 3XP: A second accessory slot ramps up the amount of power we can draw from in our play area. Antikythera takes up one slot, the other is taken up by either the Dial or the Elder Sign Amulet. Both the Dial and the ESA eventually run out (either of charges or out of horror soak), so getting a third slot is not worth it here, the two can share one slot.
We are able to laser-focus this hard on a couple high impact cards because as a Seeker/Rogue, Lucius has access to very strong level 0 cards. The truth of the matter is that his cards work perfectly well even at a base level. Unlike a Guardian or Mystic that would feel pressed to upgrade their weapons and spells, a Seeker can get away with this sort of extravaganza because cards like Mag Glasses and Milan will see them all the way to the finale. Seekers also have the card draw to find these high value assets, this is especially true for Lucius who can draw an obscene amount of cards once he starts getting the rewards for evasion flowing.
For the other 5xp, i threw some at each of the three pillars we built our deck on now: Investigation, Evasion, sanity protection.
+2 Lockpicks – 1xp each: These replace the Flashlights of the level 0 list. While Lockpicks can only be used once per turn, they do allow us to put our considerable agility to work for getting clues. Even without any other modifiers, Lucius tests at 9 vs shroud with Lockpicks, which makes oversucceeding easy. This ensures that he won’t break his lockpicks and also works towards putting that oversuccess by 5 for Antikythera on the table.
+3 Doppelgänger – 1xp (for all three): Funfact, Lucius doesn’t require you to evade an enemy at his location to get a clue. Doppelgänger allows Lucius to remote evade enemies, and there’s a couple of uses for this. You can throw this on any location you pass and next time an enemy is drawn with a spawn instruction of “empty location”, you can drop it right into the trap. You can also place Doppelgänger on your location right after evading a Hunter enemy. That way, you can evade the thing again after it tries to hunt after you even if you already moved on. Bonus points if you also put a Doppelgänger into the location the Hunter moved into. That’s a lot of shenanigans for 1xp.
+2 Dreams of the Clay – 1xp each: The idea with these is to commit them to any treachery that tests agility, easily pass the test and then put them into play to later cancel a willpower treachery that you wouldn’t be able to pass. This is a neat bit of reassurance against whatever the encounter deck might try to stop you.
We can’t just add new stuff to the deck, we also have to make some cuts from our level 0 deck, of course. The cards i removed for this proposed list are:
–2 Flashlights: These simply got directly upgraded into Lockpicks.
-1 Forensic Kit: Their main reason to exist in the deck was healing some horror. With the ESA and Dreams of the Clay in the deck, I feel comfortable taking one of them out now. We’ll keep on of them in for emergencies, but since we plan on ending up with a Lockpicks in one hand and a Mag Glass in the other, it’s not a card I hope to need.
-3 Uncanny Specimen: These were in the deck as filler and are no longer required.
-1 Hyperawareness: This was the worst card in the level 0 deck and an easy cut to make.
-2 Backstab: Presumably, Michael is upgrading his deck at the same pace as we do. As he gets more powerful, we can assume that he’ll make this emergency measure no longer necessary for us.
As for priorities, i think Antikythera is the first thing to get. It’s just so good and nothing else in this deck comes even close to its impact on the game.
Options for upgrades
Honestly, not that many. At a limited card pool like this, we’ll be taking what we can!
One thing that is worth addressing is that extraordinary focus on the accessory slot though. If that’s not what you want to do, i would still strongly advise you to go for the Antikythera. That card is incredibly strong for Lucius and i don’t see skipping it as a realistic option. In that case, you will of course be ditching the Dial and its upgrade. The Elder Sign Amulet as well. This leaves you with 10xp you can put towards other things. My suggestion would be a pair of Cryptic Researches (4xp each) to find your Antikythera. The other two XP can go towards whatever else… maybe a Scientific Study Grant to give you the option of ending up with 2 Mag Glasses, a Forensic Kit and a Lockpick all in play at the same time?
You can also go for Charisma, opening up your ally slot in a similar way to what i did here with the accessories. At a basic card pool level, there is not a whole lot here though. Alton O’Connell gives some extra agility which is fine but probably not worth running Charisma for. Research Librarian fetches up the signature asset which is neat for sure but again not really good enough on its own to justify 3XP. Leo De Luca is great, but unless your plan is to play Memories of Another Life and cheat him out that way, he’s probably too expensive. That being said, Memories is a fantastic card and if your collection has at least a little bit more in it than the basic level i am assuming here, it starts to look really attractive.
Over to you, Mr. McGlen
Overall, this looks pretty good! This is definitely a deck i feel comfortable in taking into a campaign, both the level 0 and the level 20 version seem perfectly capable. Let’s hope Michael has similar luck. One thing that we’ve already seen today is that the Rogue card pool at Core + TDC isn’t at all concerned with giving extra resources to the investigator, which is usually a major theme of them. So that’s an immediate concern that i have when we are talking about our firearm centric fighter. We’ll see how it works out in part 2.
