
Alright, now that I’ve gone and given everything some sort of ranking, I can go ahead and collect all those and do one of the Internet’s favorite things: A tierlist. Multiple of them, even!
Let’s start with the campaigns.
(Click here to get back to the compendium’s hub page)
Campaign Tierlist
If I take the rankings and just plop them into a table and sort any ties within their tiers, this is what i get:

However, for my personal tierlist, there are two important things here that i do want to throw in to make it reflect my thoughts on the campaigns better:

Innsmouth as a 6-scenario campaign is just straight up tier 1 to me, it’s pretty much everything that I want from the game.. And Return to Forgotten Age I rate so highly that it makes TFA overtake Carcosa as well. No significant adjustments to anything else, I do not think that the Returns to Carcosa, TCU or Dunwich change anything about where they place on the list. You’ll also note that i left Night of the Zealot off of the table, i don’t think it competes with these full campaigns. For the same reason, i am also only looking at Dream-Eaters as the combined dual-campaign here and am ignoring the rankings I handed to each sub-campaign.
The bottom three of these rankings (TDE, Dunwich, TCU) are campaigns that I all feel very little motivation to return to right now. It’s actually possible that these won’t be leaving the shelf anymore. The top 3 are always my first thing i gravitate towards. And the four in the middle are definitely always at least in consideration.
So as I type this out, I am realizing that something did change about my perception of the campaigns, even when their relative order didn’t: I used to divide the campaigns in my head into the five very good ones and the five okay ones with a rather big gulf in the middle between Drowned City and Edge of the Earth. Since I simultaneously warmed up to Edge and Scarlet Keys over time and also cooled slightly on Hemlock, there are now three blocks that I’d group together.
I don’t really have much more to say here that i didn’t already say on the pages of the individual campaigns, so let’s move into the scenarios.
Tier 5
I’ll go tier by tier, starting at the bottom. Here’s the six scenarios that I slapped into this tier:

The above overview (and all the ones to follow) is already sorted within their sub-tier: The further up it is, the better I think it is. The further down it is, the closer it is to the rank below. If you’ve been reading my site for a while, especially when it comes to this sort of ranking, then what forms the bottom of the list here probably is no surprise: I rag on Wages, Shades and Congress pretty regularly. Devourer Below and U&U are community-wide generally accepted to be a low point. Seeing Doom of Eztli this far down is a bit more surprising, but i really do not like the original scenario at all. It’s worth pointing out that Return to Doom of Eztli would get a Tier 3- from me.
Tier 4

“Maybe a bit boring, maybe a bit frustrating” is what i put forward as my original definition for Tier 4. And that’s really what this is for the most part: For one, all those low engagement scenarios like Heart of the Elders II, Echoes of the Past or Where Doom Awaits. And then also some scenarios with frustrating difficulty like the Boundary Beyond or Where the Gods Dwell.
The one entry here that I almost feel a bit sorry for is Hemlock House. Putting it in the company of things like Into the Maelstrom or Thousand Shapes is underselling it maybe a bit. Imagine a Tier 4++ just for it if you will! While you are at it, feel free to imagine a 4– tier for Fatal Mirage as well. I am well aware that some of my aversion for that scenario is partly irrational, but what can i do. It is what it is.
Tier 3

“The Average scenario, enjoyable but not outstanding”. Certainly true for most of these, but there are definitely a few in there that do stand out. Like, say what you will about City of Archives, but it’s not your average scenario. And neither is Fate of the Vale, but for Fate I already called out its placement on the list as an aberration on the Hemlock Vale page.
So how close were the entries on the upper and lower bounds of the tier to getting into Tier 2- or 4+? On the upper end… not very close. Lost Sister and Point of No Return read very much like your average scenario to me. Notably, i had Point of No Return in tier 2 in the past and even further in the past i used to even name it my highlight from Dream-Eaters, but that veneer has worn off mostly. Perfectly fine scenario of course, but nothing more. Shattered Aeons is a good finale that i enjoy, but i can’t see it moving up either. Now, on the lower end however… Phantom of Truth is safe, i think. As a reminder, Phantom is here with a sort of combined rank of its two versions. One of it is a Tier 4 for sure, but the other is good enough to compensate. Now, Lair of Dagon, Dogs of War and Ice and Death II however… yeah if i had done this another day these may very well have gotten a Tier 4+ instead. I mean, i am not going to go back and alter my rankings after the fact now, but am i really putting Lair of Dagon over Hemlock House here? That doesn’t seem quite right? Oh well. I suppose it doesn’t matter in the big picture.
Tier 2

This is where the really nice scenarios start and I took quite some time putting these into an order until it looked right to me. My big takeaway from this Tier is that there are a couple scenarios I maybe don’t give quite the amount of respect that they deserve, that I generally tend to not think about when it comes to examples of particularly good scenarios. Riddles and Rain is a good example, as are Silent Heath and Dancing Mad. We talk about scenarios like In Too Deep, Waking Nightmare or Secret Name all the time and obviously there are also some real darlings in here like Midnight Masks, Depths of Yoth and Curtain Call. But something like On Thin Ice or Forbidden Peaks could maybe get some more attention when it comes to things they do particularly well.
That 2- tier is huge! 15 scenarios alone are in that one and the tier does span quite the range, with Apiary and Weaver on one side and Dealings in the Dark and Ice and Death III on the low end. I may have been too stingy and should have ranked some of the top end into Tier 2 proper. Or maybe moved some of the lower end into Tier 3+? Ultimately, it doesn’t matter, the lines are drawn arbitrarily and based on vibes. It’s all relative in the end.
Also always worth pointing out: Seven of the campaign openers are somewhere in tier 2. That Curtain Call ranks highest among them is no surprise, but before I started this project I could not have predicted Riddles and Rain being right behind it. Makes perfect sense in hindsight however, i just tend to forget about it because TSK as a campaign is not one that is on my mind that much. Does that mean that Curtain Call wins the contest among the opening scenarios? Not quite. One of them made it into …
Tier 1

And that’s the top end. Like the lowest tier, this is probably not a huge surprise if you’ve been following my blog for a while, because I’ve been droning on about these for a long time now.
Sorting them against each other was surprisingly simple, i didn’t really have much controversy with myself over any of these. Light in the Fog beats out Oath and is without a doubt my favorite piece of Arkham right now. That my top five scenarios are all from Carcosa and Innsmouth is quite the statement. Carcosa even puts in a third one into the Top 10: my former top spot, Pallid Mask. Grand Vault sneaking in there is definitely a surprise. This is one of those placements that i might think differently about in a year or three, but for now i am happy to put it up here.
Ten scenarios in total in this tier, so conveniently this image doubles as “DerBK’s Top Ten Scenarios from Chapter 1“. Three each from Innsmouth and Carcosa and we got scenarios representing Forgotten Age, Hemlock Vale, Drowned City and Dunwich as well.
Putting it all together: Scenario Tierlist
Here’s the money shot:

Some stats:
A total of 87 scenarios across 10 campaigns (+NotZ) were ranked.
10 (11%) of them made it into Tier 1.
32 (37%) are in Tier 2.
26 (30%) are in Tier 3.
13 (15%) scenarios got into Tier 4.
6 (7%) got Tier 5.
It’s a top-heavy distribution, but that shouldn’t be a surprise. I like this game and accordingly It makes sense that I would rank two thirds of the roster in the good to great range of Tier 2 and Tier 3. You can however also flip this sentiment: About two in nine scenarios ranks as “frustrating/boring” (Tier 4) or “actively offputting” (Tier 5), slightly less than two per campaign on average.
A word on chapter 2
As for chapter 2, we’ll see. I don’t think that the three-parters like Children of Blood could meaningfully be compared on a campaign level with the ones from chapter 1. I did exclude NotZ from the campaign rankings as well, for the same reason. A three-part campaign will always be inferior to an eight-part campaign, that’s just not something that’s even worth arguing about. The real interesting bit will be the five-parter. We already have some six-parters on the list: Hemlock Vale is one, TSK is often one, i treat Innsmouth like one. Who even knows how to count Dream-Eaters. So that will hopefully be a better comparison on a campaign level.
On a scenario level, the comparison is worth doing. Chances are that I will do a chapter 2 specific tierlist a year or two down the road and then we can merge that with this one? Something like that. Still plenty time to wait and see how all of this shakes out.
But since I got asked already and I know that I’ll be asked again in the future if I leave this out, let me just throw out my preliminary rankings for Brethren of Ash: Spreading Flames is Tier 2-, same as the Gathering. I like it more than Gathering, but not enough to rank up. Smoke and Mirrors is a clean Tier 2, a half-step below Masks. Queen of Ash gets a Tier 3+. I like the trek through the sewers well enough, but not enough to break out of the “average, solid Arkham” tier. And for Children of Blood, I’d say something very similar: Tier 2- for River of Blood which is kept from more with some wonky mechanics, but I quite like starting on a boss fight. Then it’s Tier 2+ for New Horizons, I particularly enjoy the night version and the relentless combat in it. This genuinely has a shot to scratch at the lower end of Tier 1- for me, but the day version felt a lot less special so as a composite rating for both versions this does probably belong somewhere in the Tier 2 range. And finally i’ll put Tier 3- on Blood Money which doesn’t hold up to the first two scenarios, but isn’t awful either. Both of those campaigns have a good opener, a very strong middle and then an okay finish. I do like Queen of Ash a lot more than Blood Money, but Children of Blood on a whole beats Brethren of Ash. I’d put both of these three-parters over chapter 1’s Night of the Zealot and also over the A-campaign from Dream-Eaters. The B-side of TDE I’d rank over Brethren of Ash, but not over Children of Blood? Something like that? But yeah, too early to really get too delve into that further in detail. Once another two campaigns or three are added to the chapter 2 roster, we can revisit this.
Wrapping Up
And that’s It! That’s what I got for this exercise. It’s unlikely that I am going to change these chapter 1 rankings again, i’d say I got a pretty firm understanding of where i stand on them. The one campaign where i could see myself looking at it slightly differently in a year or two would be the most recent one, Drowned City. But not in a way that would upset the list in a significant way.
