Designing a fan-made Return to the Dreamlands #6: State of the Project

Intro

It’s been a hot second since my last entry in the Diary for the custom Return to Dream-Eaters. What happened?

Well, the plan was to finish up one side of the Dream-Eaters campaign before moving into the next one. Entry #6 was originally supposed to detail all the final changes to The Web of Dreams and include a TTS playable version of that side of the campaign attached. However, that’s not really coming together the way i want it to right now. Especially the Return to the Point of No Return is giving me a bit of grief. I have this notion that i should do something with the ghouls and Pickman in this scenario, but nothing that i threw at the wall managed to stick so far. There’s also the whole thing with the Black Cat where i was tinkering with cards referencing your choice with regards to it and that is also not coming together. Bottom line is, i think i hit a bit of a wall there and i need to refocus on something else for now and get back to it later. So that’s what i am doing now, starting to peek at what i have so far for campaign A, The Dream-Quest.

With all the scheduled Hemlock Vale coverage being done, it’s about high time to get this going again!

State of the Project

So, since it’s been a while, let’s take stock of where i am with this.

Player cards:
Mostly locked in, but i am still changing details on some of them. I shared a rundown of the designs in entry #5. Since then i did redesign both of the Mystic cards (Open Gate, Mind’s Eye). The weakness locations are still the thing that needs the most work here. Aside from the weaknesses, i believe i am in a good place with these now though and i don’t foresee any major changes to them.

Encounter replacements:
Looking good. The two cards that were giving me grief the last time i posted about the URtTDE on here were Freezing Blood (the replacement for Crypt Chill) and Looming Evils (the replacement for Ancient Evils), both of which i tweaked and updated over the last weeks (Freezing Blood, Looming Evils).

The Black Cat:
I had some ideas for having more consequences from your choices regarding the cat. None really felt all that great in the end so far. My current thought is to just leave it be.

Campaign A:
– Rt Gates of Sleep: A bit of a boring scenario and the first half is so non-interactive that there’s not much to grip at with a Return either. I fix the heavy punishment for staying on the path (i don’t think you should get rewarded for doing so, but getting screwed over is just an unnecessary feel bad). The Woods gain some extra locations and a hook for a later payoff. Overall this looks fine to me, even if it doesn’t fundamentally solve Gates of Sleeps primary issue of being just a bit too bland.
– Rt Kadath: This is still a big construction site. I had an idea of introducing travel events that would happen whenever changing islands. Those would interfere with the travels, making you change course or add something new to wherever you go. This all ended up a bit too fiddly for its own good, though. My current thought is that i am going to scrap that idea and start fresh. So, in conclusion, Rt Kadath isn’t really all that far along yet.
– Rt Dark Side: I like what i have here and this is mostly done, i think. A rather flashy change in that the players meet Cadet Maheswaran, a projection of the real-world Dr. Maheswaran that is watching over their sleeping bodies (provided she survived Waking Nightmare…). Also some more classic Return To style location replacements to change up some things. Looks good to me!
– Rt Where the Gods Dwell: I’m not going to lie, I am very excited about what i have going on here. I spend a considerable amount of card budget on making the finale with Nyarlathothep more dramatic. Among other things, everyone is going to encounter the Nyarlathothep amalgamation in the end now. I also attempt to fix the bad player count scaling of the scenario through a combination of extra turns available and scaling the encounter deck size by player count which will help solo and 2p groups with finding the hidden cards they need. These scenario changes aren’t fully done yet, but i am about 80% towards where i want to be, i think.

Campaign B:
– Rt Waking Nightmare: Talked about here. Subtle changes, but overall this looks good to me!
– Rt Thousand Shapes: Talked about here. Large sweeping changes to streamline the scenario. I consider this finished, too.
– Rt No Return: Talked about here. I think this still needs work. I like the Tar Tyrant, but the rest of it is all a bit flat and doesn’t change anything much.
– Rt Weaver: Talked about here. I am happy with how these changes play. The extra movement rules for the spider are nice and the nerfed clue damage also plays well.

So what’s happening next?

To identify the big road blocks: The Return to No Return and the Return to Kadath are the two big ones that i am still very unsatisfied with. Rt Gods Dwell also needs a good amount of tinkering with its numbers. And the weakness locations need to get to a less wordy, less awkward spot.
Honestly. the rest is not all that dramatic. For the most part, this is looking promising, but as is so often the case, the last bit is what takes the longest.
I also want to rebuild the TTS implementation from scratch which is going to take a good amount of time.

Sooo… still don’t expect the release of this thing too soon. But it’s coming along and even though i didn’t talk about the project much in recent months, it is still slowly progressing in the background. But i simply can not make it a priority for me right now, so who knows when it gets there. I am shooting for a release before Winds of Winter, but if i don’t manage that, i should at least beat Doors of Stone?

I do plan on continuing the “dev diary” soon though, with my notes on Return to Beyond the Gates of Sleep.

6 Replies to “Designing a fan-made Return to the Dreamlands #6: State of the Project”

  1. Hi,

    I just wanted to say I’m unreasonably excited by this project. I’ve appreciated your in-depth articles for some time, I’m very much looking forward what you come up with on the designer’s side!

    1. Hey, I see you keep dev diaries and I also read that you were already kind of overwhelmed with current projects, so what I’m about to say is probably irrelevant for now, but…
      I and I think many others would be extremely interested if you eventually produced some sort of synthesis of your encounter / player cards development in a “Fanmade guidelines” as you certainly put a ton of interesting thought on balance and what makes a smart encounter or a good weakness.
      There’s a lot of interest out there for producing Fanmade material (including now mine), and many are mainly driven by creative ideas, theme, and would greatly benefit from guidance on all the matters treated here ;)
      Alwaus looking forward to reading more from you. Happy development !

      1. Now that Hemlock Vale is mostly in the books, i do actually have time to spend on something else. I don’t really see myself fiddling with the URtTDE full time, after all :)
        Your suggestion is a good one and one i did think about before. It’d be a pretty massive article or, more likely, article series but something like going over what i consider good design would be interesting indeed. I didn’t think about framing it as a resource for fanmade content before and i think i do like that.
        I’ll think about how I could structure such a series. Great suggestion, thanks.

  2. Just a heads-up, Freezing Blood looks like it still blanks weaknesses.

    Other than that, thanks for the update. Don’t worry, I read fanfiction, I understand that creative endeavors take time. Looking forward to seeing what you’ve got cooking, especially for Where the Gods Dwell.

    1. I have decided that i am good with Freezing Blood disabling weaknesses. It still does blank all other hand items as well, so even if it does for example blank the Necronomicon or the King in Yellow, it does have a negative effect. Seems like this would actually even be a cause for interesting decisions to make about whether you’d want to keep Freezing Blood in play or not.

      1. That is an interesting idea. Lol, got the visual of Minh players crossing their fingers and hoping to draw Freezing Blood so they don’t have to deal with The King in Yellow.

Leave a Reply