Pilgrims

Set Size4
Number of unique Cards2
RoleEnemies, Doom
Threat LevelLow
# of scenarios2
Appears in: Apiary, Court of the Ancients

My take: This set is only used in two scenarios and what’s more, only in the Western version of Apiary and the Eastern version of Court. So in a given campaign, you will encounter this set exactly once. And one of those scenarios uses it a lot better than the other…
In Apiary West, the Pilgrims are an integral part of the scenario mechanics.
However, in Court East, it’s just filler that doesn’t interact with anything.
Honestly, these enemies should just have been part of the scenario specific Apiary set, they add nothing to the 37 card tall stack of cards that is the Court of the Ancients encounter deck.

# in the encounter set: 1

Threat: Low to Mid

I am being a bit generous there with the threat assessment and am just going to assume that you can’t just ignore him completely. Sometimes that is going to be the case however and then you just have this dork sitting there all Aloof and doing nothing because the only three Cultists in the encounter deck don’t show up.
When they do, those cultists do get some considerable bonuses. What’s going to be easier for you? Punching through that +2 fight to kill those other cultists? Or going after the 3 health Aloof guy? Most of the time the answer is likely going to be that you’ll ignore the Leader and just take the extra difficulty in fighting the cultist followers.
Of course, if you do have any anti-Aloof tech or other ways to quickly dispose of a 3 health non-Elite enemy, then this is a good target.

# in the encounter set: 3

Threat: Low

How often do you end up being attacked by a Ghoul? Likely the answer to this is “barely ever”. So that gives an indication how often their ability on attack is relevant… barely ever. Now, the Pilgrim Leader can boost these guys up to a 4/2/2 and that does make them more difficult to defeat. But i’d argue that any fighter worth their salt still should find little trouble here. Them gaining Hunter (and double attack for double the doom) is kind of neat, however. So you will want to defeat them, even if they don’t have a Leader boosting them right now just because they might get that later on.
Still, they are a basic 2/2/2 enemy, so defeating them is no ordeal at all.

4 Replies to “Pilgrims”

  1. It seems to me that Drowned City’s encounter sets are, on average, on the weaker side. Pilgrims, Domination, Deep Ones, and Cosmic Legacy all seem underwhelming in some regard, either due to the cards outright being weak (“Cthulhu fhtagn!” is criminal) or there simply being a lack of synergies (shuffling Deep Ones into the Innsmouth scenarios, where there actually are Deep Ones to affect, would be terrifying). Would you agree with this assessment?

    1. I’d agree with the second part (lack of synergies) but not necessarily with the first part (on average weak).

      I think the encounter cards and sets by themselves are largely fine to good, but the way they are put together into encounter decks lets them down. The decks are too big and lack cohesion.
      A set like Pilgrims could easily be a part of something good, but it is missing pieces that work with it. I actually quite like the Deep One set and think it would be excellent if it was used in encounter decks that look like the ones in Innsmouth… but this campaign simply doesn’t use it well

  2. Quick note: Pilgrim Leader only increases fight, so those Pilgrim Acolytes are 4/2/2 when he is present

    Pilgrim Leader is actually very memorable for me, as when we push through Court of the Ancients, we drawed this, had to place it in an out-of-reach location due to that empty if able clause, and 2 of the team have a Cultist as their weakness (Silver Twilight Acolyte, plus I never know Rita’s Hoods is a cultist). 4/3/3 and 5/3/3 with hunter and relentless that keeps coming back is not fun to deal with :(

Leave a Reply