Updates to the Investigator Tierlists for 2025

Intro

One year ago, on January 1st 2024, i published a Comprehensive Investigator Power Ranking. That was a truly massive article that honestly probably should have been a series of like 5 articles or something. Opinions were uttered, statements were made. Some of them more controversial than others. In any case, i have been thinking about doing this whole massive thing again… but i don’t think that’s quite warranted.
Similarly, half a year ago, I did a ranking by enjoyment. Not quite as overblown of an article as the other one, but still rather huge. Same deal there… i do like the idea of doing this again, but not in full.
So what I will do instead is go over the pool of investigators, consider their 2024 rankings in both of last year’s tierlists. And if there is no change or much to talk about, i’ll just quickly move on so I can spend some more time on the parts that are actually interesting. Like, giving my takes on the new investigators from Drowned City which i will do after i went over the investigators that already were on the list last year.

I’ll be referring to my arguments in those previous two articles a lot instead of repeating them here, so feel free to open both in another browser tab for reference.
Also, check out the ranks and their criteria in those previous articles as i will just keep using them here.

Oh right, and i won’t be doing the whole Tiermaker.com thing this time around, that was a huge pain to edit into the article for just some visual distraction. I’ll leave that sort of visualization to the Youtubers. While that makes the article less sexy visually, it does shave two hours off of the time i spend doing this, so it just is what it is. Maybe next year i will do the whole thing from the top instead of an update and go the extra mile again. This year you’ll have to be content with just some red and green text color on the ranks that changed compared to last year.

[EDIT: Oops, i forgot about Parallel Jenny. I’ll edit her in later. EDIT#2: Done.]

Anways, with that we are off to Guardian. Roland, you’re first.

Guardian

Roland Banks: B // A
Previously ranked at B for power and A for enjoyment.
Nothing new on this front, moving on. I played the parallel Roland once, but otherwise i haven’t checked in on him all year.

Zoey Samaras: A // A+
Previously ranked at A+ for power and S for enjoyment.
I think i was a bit high on Zoey last year. Ranking her in power right next to heavy weights like Daniela, Agnes or Nathaniel was blatant favoritism for one of my darlings. Speaking of darlings, she earned her S for enjoyment last year pretty much completely on the back of the fact that her deckbuilding and resource advantage enable a great deal of strategies for her. I very much enjoy building decks for her, but that’s of course only one half of the equation and during the game she doesn’t really scream S-tier to me.
I’ll put her down a notch on both rankings, but make no mistake, Zoey is still amazing.

Mark Harrigan: S // B+
Previously ranked at S for power and B+ for enjoyment.
Yep, that checks out.

Leo Anderson: A+ // A+
Previously ranked at A for power and A for enjoyment.
In my 2024 power ranking i said this: “I wavered a lot between awarding Leo the A+ instead of the A, but decided to use the distinction here to put a space between him and Zoey who i believe is just more straightforward and direct.” I am flipping the script on this and will be ranking up Leo while ranking down Zoey. Leo gets more and more great toys, his offclass access gives him more and more powerful stuff. Drowned City will give him even more. I still view him more as “The Firearm Guy” instead of “The Ally guy” but that’s fine. He simply is front of my mind when building decks very often.

Carolyn Fern: B+ // B
Previously ranked at B+ for power and B for enjoyment.
Sure, that seems fine. I still didn’t revisit her at all and also didn’t feel like wanting to. Maybe that’s a sign that i should drop her down to C in the enjoyment ranking, but i’ll let her coast by this once.

Tommy Muldoon: A // A+
Previously ranked at A for power and A+ for enjoyment.
I like this guy. Unchanged.

Sister Mary: D // D
Previously ranked at C for power and D for enjoyment.
I think it’s time to acknowledge that every other bless focused investigator does her thing better, with better abilities and cardpools. Hell, there are non-bless investigators like Tommy that do Bless decks better than her. Down to D.

Lily Chen: A // A
Previously ranked at A for power and A for enjoyment.
Lily is constantly just a little bit away from me wanting to give her the A+ in enjoyment. The thing that is missing is mostly something more compelling to put into her level 0 deck. Level 0 Mystic is just so awkward for her and i am never really happy with anything i put together there. Still, i like her and i like her unique journey over the course of a campaign. No changes.

Carson Sinclair: B // D
Previously Unranked for power, with a D for enjoyment.
Oh no. I forgot about this when i started this article. I weaseled myself out of giving ranks for Carson and Amina last time, but i suppose i have to cough up my take now, huh. Fine. I despise this one and how he somehow communicates that playing support means letting other people play instead of you. There are so many more interesting and interactive ways of supporting other players that still let you play your own game, too. He gives an action and thus i won’t be able to justify putting him below an upper B for power, no matter how much i want to.

Wilson Richards: B // C
Previously ranked at a speculative B+ for power and C for enjoyment.
He’s fine. I like that he does a solid job of being a seeker in the Guardian class. Kind of one-dimensional though and after doing his thing once or twice, i find myself less compelled to do it again. I ranked him at a speculative B+ last year (he wasn’t released yet) and i’ll slightly notch that down to a B. He’s just fine, nothing more, nothing less.

Nathaniel Cho: A+ // A
Previously ranked at A+ for power and A for enjoyment.
Similarly one-dimensional, but unlike Wilson he packs a punch. Literally. His gameplay is also more dynamic and fun to execute than Wilson’s which is enough to let him stick around in the upper tiers. Unchanged.

Parallel Roland Banks: A // A
Previously Unranked for power, with a speculative A for enjoyment.
Over the course of the last year, i actually got to play this dude. Not for a full campaign, because Darkham kicked my ass… But enough to get a better understanding of him. He’s good. Better than base Roland, i think. The Directives are powerful and not that difficult to work around, giving him a more consistent payoff than base Roland’s reliance on an enemy to get his free clue (at least in 2p). I liked it. Probably not going to play him too often anyways, but that’s mostly anti-parallel bias on my end.

Parallel Zoey: (A?) // (B?)
Previously unranked for power, with a speculative B for enjoyment.
Still didn’t play her, Kohaku has given me an outlet for all the bless and curse shenanigans i could wish for. I think my reasoning for a speculative A on the power scale still checks out, so i’ll just keep these rankings unchanged.

Seeker

Daisy Walker: S // A+
Previously ranked at S for power and A+ for enjoyment.
God, i love Daisy. Unchanged.

Rex Murphy: A+ // B+
Previously ranked at A+ for power and B+ for enjoyment.
I got some snark for not putting him in S like the tradition commands, but I stand by this one. Actually i even feel like i am being a bit generous towards Rex here by squeezing him in at the lower ranks of A+. At the end of the day, a clue is nothing special for a Seeker, we all assume that we can pick those up for an action anyways. Considering that Rex also has to put some effort into getting to the point where he oversucceeds consistently, his investigator ability is outpaced by several others that give something close to an action. With how many “card for a clue” cards are out there these days, you can even argue that the Seekers that gain an extra card per turn can outpace or at least match Rex if they want.
On the enjoyment side, a big part of his draw for me is that he can play green cards. Now that we are getting the official 5-2 Seeker-rogue in the next set, that will likely eat into his appeal for me. Unchanged for now, though.

Minh Thi Phan: A+ // C
Previously ranked at A+ for power and C for enjoyment.
I am not sure i have even thought about this investigator once during the last year. Unchanged.

Ursula Downs: C // C
Previously ranked at C for power and B for enjoyment.
The space for investigators that gain clues and evade enemies is getting crowded and Uschi just isn’t on the same level as the rest of them. Lucius is yet another one that is out for her lunch money and she barely has any left in the first place.

Joe Diamond: B+ // S
Previously ranked at B+ for power and S for enjoyment.
No changes here. Love this guy. Played him with Tony through a Return to TFA run which was a riot. Watching two investigators get bullied by the encounter deck nonstop never gets old.

Mandy Thompson: A+ // B
Previously ranked at A+ for power and B for enjoyment.
Another one i may not have thought about all year. Sure, seems fine.

Amanda Sharpe: A // B+
Previously ranked at A for power and B+ for enjoyment.
This is a ranking that i have gotten some side eye for, as Amanda is often considered to be one of the best investigators in the game. And while i do agree that her highs are really high, i think she is definitely kept back by the times when she sets herself up. It’s all hills and valleys with her. The turns where she draws six cards or picks up six clues off the back of Perceptions and Deductions are super impressive, but when you average them out with the turns where she walks around as a 2/2/2/2 with some random card tucked under her that gives her a will icon or something, then it starts looking a lot more fair. Fwiw, i put her on the higher end of A, but i don’t think she’s an A+ or even an S.

Monterey Jack: A // A
Previously ranked at A for power and A for enjoyment.
Hangs in a similarly crowded space as Ursula does. His yellow/green card access that was able to stand in for the missing Seeker-rogue was a major selling point for me, too. I suspect that Lucius is going to push Jack down a tier next year, but for now i will let him stay unchanged.

Vincent Lee: B+ // B
Previously ranked at B+ for power and B for enjoyment.
Sure. No new thoughts on this one.

Kate Winthrop: A // B+
Previously ranked at speculative A for power and a C for enjoyment.
Pretty neat. A unique twist on the evadey seeker, with solid hooks into other Seeker archetypes as well. I liked my campaign with her well enough and since then i pulled her investigator cards out several times during deckbuilding as a consideration.
I also want to take a second here to apologize for my absolutely unhinged reading of her during the power rankings, i have no idea what sort of short circuit i was having in my brain when i penned that deranged rambling passage.

Harvey Walters: A+ // C
Previously ranked at A+ for power and C for enjoyment.
Boring, but powerful. No changes. Really the only reason i don’t give him the S for the power rankings is because i don’t want him on a level with Daisy who is just superior in almost every way.

Parallel Daisy: C // D
Previously ranked at C for power and D for enjoyment.
Oh right, that one exists. Still not sure why.

Parallel Rex: (A?) // (A?)
Previously unranked for power, with a speculative A for enjoyment.
I didn’t get around to play him yet, but his gimmick still reads interesting to me. Cluedrop is a powerful archetype, he gets to cheat at that… i think that’s enough to give him a speculative A for power? Sure, seems fine.

Rogue

Skids O’Toole: B // A
Previously ranked at D for power and A for enjoyment.
Now, this guy here. There is a distinct difference between pre-Hemlock and post-Hemlock Skids. The previous rankings actually reflect that. The power rankings were done before i got to play Skids with today’s card pool. The enjoyment ranking reflects how pleased i was playing him now. I have spent a considerable amount of time building for and playing with Skids this year, more than in the four years before together. The enjoyment ranking stays, but I am shooting him in the power rankings all the way up from D to B. I have absolutely no reservations putting him next to or even a bit ahead of Roland.

Jenny Barnes: C // C
Previously ranked at C for power and C for enjoyment.
She’s certainly not moving up. And i don’t think i feel about her strongly enough to rank her down to D. Fine, unchanged.

Sefina Russeau: B // S
Previously ranked at B for power and S for enjoyment.
Will Transfiguration be good enough for her to elevate her a tier in the power rankings next year? We’ll see next year, i guess. This year nothing has changed. She’s still solid but not super good and she’s still an absolute delight.

Finn Edwards: A // B+
Previously ranked at A for power and B+ for enjoyment.
Honestly, i didn’t really think much about him this year. Kate and Alessandra have sort of filled his role when i was looking for it. And Skids. So much Skids gaming this year Oo
No changes.

Preston Fairmont: B+ // A+
Previously ranked at B+ for power and A+ for enjoyment.
No notes on Preston this year.

Tony Morgan: S // A+
Previously ranked at S for power and A+ for enjoyment.
Is it weird that Skids is starting to see play for me for things that i would have done with Tony before? It’s not enough for me give Tony a full rank down to A in the enjoyment rankings, however. No changes.

Trish Scarborough: A+ // B+
Previously ranked at A+ for power and B+ for enjoyment.
I am afraid Alessandra ate her lunch this year because she was the hot new thing. With Lucius coming up this may be another rough year for Trish coming up, too.
Unchanged for now.

Bob Jenkins: A // A
Previously ranked at A for power and A for enjoyment.
I cannot wait for pulling out the Gatling Gun with Bob. It’s going to be glorious. Over the course of the previous year, i considered him during deckbuilding a few times, but he didn’t see actual play. Fair enough. Unchanged.

Kymani Jones: B // C
Previously ranked at B for power and C for enjoyment.
I am having troubles coming up with situations where I’d want to play them. Maybe Nose to the Grindstone will help, but tbh i doubt it. No changes.

Alessandra Zorzi: A+ // A+
Previously ranked at a speculative A for power, with A+ for enjoyment.
I think she deserves that A+ in power, that extra action does a lot of work. And since she can play a decent amount of good Parley in her deck, she isn’t even depending on the campaign for that. Trish probably edges her out in power just a bit, but she is a lot more interesting to play and build decks for in my opinion.

Winifred Habbamock: S // S
Previously ranked at S for power and S for enjoyment.
I do not have a S+ tier and until i do there will be no changes with Winifred.

Parallel Skids: B+ // B+
Previously ranked at a speculative B+ for power and another speculative B+ for enjoyment.
Another previously unplayed Parallel investigator that i managed to finally give a play this year. The B+ in both lists seem right to me. He was fine, but i didn’t particularly enjoy him. He was solidly capable, but not really in a way that made him stick out to me.

Parallel Monterey: (B+?) // (B+?)
Previously unranked for power, with a speculative B+ for enjoyment.
Didn’t get around to this one. To come up with a speculative power ranking for him, i’d say that his ability is quite a bit worse than the consistent income of cash and cards of his canon version which i rated at A. Soo… let’s just call this a B+?

Mystic

Agnes Baker: A+ // A
Previously ranked at A+ for power and A for enjoyment.
This seems right to me. No changes.

Jim Culver: D // D
Previously ranked at D for power and D for enjoyment.
*shrug*
No changes.

Akachi Onyele: A // A
Previously ranked at A for power and A for enjoyment.
The problem with these investigators that are basically centered on a stale part of the card pool (the spell assets) is that it would take one remarkable shake-up in the card pool for me to re-evaluate them. Unchanged.

Father Mateo: C // D
Previously ranked at C for power and D for enjoyment.
For now unchanged, but there is some potentially game changing stuff for him on the card spoiler for Drowned City right now. I am as tickled by the thought of using his 5XP to buy Memories of Another Life to fix his card access as i am by the one of changing him to another investigator once i used his autofail negation with Transfiguration.
This year, no changes though.

Diana Stanley: B+ // A
Previously ranked at B+ for power and A+ for enjoyment.
I didn’t play her in a while and also didn’t seriously consider it all year. I feel like that’d be a requirement to hold that A+ enjoyment tier. Down to the top of A with her for now.

Marie Lambeau: A // A
Previously ranked at A+ for power and A for enjoyment.
I think i slightly overvalued her last year, which i also confirmed by playing her through a campaign. She is great when she gets to do her thing, that free action is really nice. But some scenarios simply do not allow for doom play and that leaves you a bit behind other mystics. I want to knock her down just a bit from the low A+ i gave her to a high A.

Luke Robinson: A+ // A
Previously ranked at A+ for power and A for enjoyment.
Checks out. Unchanged.

Dexter Drake: A+ // A+
Previously ranked at A for power and A+ for enjoyment.
Dexter was robbed last year when i only put him in A. Granted, it was the top spot of A, but still. The man deserves his A+, he has so many shenanigans in addition to the usual just raw power of mystics with 5 will.

Norman Withers: A+ // A+
Previously ranked at A+ for power and A+ for enjoyment.
Unchanged. Just a really excellent investigator.

Amina Zidane: D // D
Previously ranked at a speculative D for power and D for enjoyment.
Amina has one really amazing trick and that is using her ability in the first two turns to set up with 11 resources at her disposal (12 if you count the one from the first upkeep). Beyond that it looks rather grim, but that one trick is good enough that i am tempted to lift her up to C just on the back of that. Sadly her combination of bad statline with bad deckbuilding prevents her from doing anything nice with that fantastic setup though. Any tempo you win there you have to spend on making up for her shortcomings on other ends. Add on top that some scenarios simply don’t afford you the luxury of adding doom yourself and it all just doesn’t come together.

Kohaku Narukami: A // S
Previously ranked at a speculative A for power and a definite S for enjoyment.
There’s an argument to be made for A+ power on him for all the shenanigans he can get up to, but i think he’s fine in A. He requires his ramp up time and assembly to get going and often hinges on some key assets that he’ll have to find.

Gloria Goldberg: S // D
Previously ranked at S for power and D for enjoyment.
Her canon version hasn’t been released yet, so no changes here. I doubt that the new version is going to impact my views on her next year, though.

Jacqueline Fine: A // C
Previously ranked at A for power and C for enjoyment.
No changes, i barely think about this investigator.

Parallel Agnes: S // A+
Previously ranked at S for power and A+ for enjoyment.
The only parallel investigator where i wish it was a canon character. Such a good design. No changes, she rocks.

Parallel Jim: B+ // C
Previously ranked at a speculative B for power and B+ for enjoyment.
Gave him a short spin, too. Not a full campaign, but three scenarios just to see how he works. I had the impression that he was quite powerful. I estimated him at a B last year just from reading him, but both the charge replenishment and the spirit gimmick are significant sources of value that prop up the rest of him. I am not ready to accept him in the same rank as Akachi or Jaqueline, so B+ it is. As with many parallels, the sheer mess of his design takes away a lot of my enjoyment here. It’s all so unfocused and mashed together. I didn’t have an awful time, but i also have no desire to play him again soon. Low C.

Survivor

Wendy Adams: A // A+
Previously ranked at A for power and A+ for enjoyment.
No changes.

Ashcan Pete: A // B+
Previously ranked at A for power and B+ for enjoyment.
That seems right to me. No notes.

William Yorrick: A+ // S
Previously ranked at A+ for power and S for enjoyment.
Again, this looks good. He’s a beast.

Calvin Wright: C // D
Previously ranked at C for power and D for enjoyment.
Didn’t think about this guy all year except when musing about Hank stealing most of his reasons to exist.

Rita Young: A // A+
Previously ranked at B for power and A for enjoyment.
Let’s just give her that A. Why not. Make her skip over B+ and right up there. She has been doing nothing but winning for the last years, with one significant card after the next that seemed tailor made to turn her into a fighter-evader powerhouse. She has no business being down there on a level with Kymani who wishes they were as good at their job as Rita is. And you know what else, i’ll also rank her up from A to A+ for enjoyment. She has been a blast to play and i actually put her through two campaigns this year because of that.

Patrice Hathaway: C // A
Previously ranked at D for power and A for enjoyment.
There were a lot of contentious takes in my 2024 article and i got plenty of feedback on many of them, but nothing generated as many outcries as the D for Patrice. So i ended up playing her again of course. And sure, the D was probably a bit much. That being said, she depends a lot on some specific cards to do well and is prone enough to stalling out a bit that a C is really all i can justify here. I very much do enjoy the Erestor playstyle still though.

Silas Marsh: B+ // C
Previously ranked at B+ for power and C for enjoyment.
This is another one that didn’t appear on my radar all year.

Daniela Reyes: A+ // A
Previously ranked at A+ for power and A for enjoyment.
One of the best fighters in the game, this checks out. No notes.

Darrell Simmons: S // D
Previously ranked at S for power and D for enjoyment.
I do not care about Darrell. No changes.

Hank Samson: A // D
Previously ranked a speculative A for power and a C for enjoyment.
After playing him, i think my initial estimation was correct. That being said, he’s a 5 fight with little else attached. I don’t see much of a reason for him to be around when Daniela exists.

Stella Clark: A+ // B+
Previously ranked at A+ for power and B+ for enjoyment.
Didn’t revisit her, but at least considered it. Still, no changes.

Parallel Wendy: (???) // D
Previously unranked for power, with a D for enjoyment.
Completely uninterested in this heap of unconnected sentences that somehow make up an investigator. I am not even going to do a speculative power ranking here.

Parallel Ashcan: B // A
Previously ranked at a speculative B for power and A for enjoyment.
Didn’t get around to playing this one, so I’ll stick to last year’s speculation.

Neutral

Lola Hayes: C // B
Previously ranked at C for power and B for enjoyment.
No Lola for me this year, but the amount of shenanigans that one can do with Transfiguration already has me giddy. I predict some Lola decks this year. I mean, how can i not play Lolafred Habbamayes at least once this year? Until then, unchanged.

Charlie Kane: A // S
Previously ranked at A for power and S for enjoyment.
Yep, Charlie is still a blast to play. No changes.

Subject 5U-21: B+ // C
Previously ranked at a speculative A for power and C for enjoyment.
I tried this for a full campaign, didn’t care for it. Too unfocused, too big of a deck to do the interesting things and just kinda didn’t deliver anything for me that’d justify all the gimmickry. I liked the gameplay around the waxing and waning statline, but it wasn’t enough for me to want to return to playing the slime lady.

New entries!

That was all of the investigators mentioned in the ’24 rankings, but we have of course gotten some fresh blood since then. Actually it’s not that many, but we did get a new parallel investigator and of course i want to take a first look at the investigators of The Drowned City, now that we know all of them. For that, i will be switching back to the full evaluation format that i used in the Comprehensive Power Rankings and the Enjoyment Rankings. These rankings are all speculative, i have not played any of these characters yet.

[EDIT: I forgot all about Parallel Jenny initially. Foreshadowing? Anyways, here she is now.]

Parallel Jenny: B // B
Statline and Soak: Same as regular Jenny, so decidedly meh.
Investigator ability: Leo’s ability, but for Talents instead of allies. Kinda weird, Talent doesn’t really strike me as a build-around trait, but if that’s what you got going on then the ability isn’t bad. It’s hard to argue against a free action and a buck, after all. She also gets to throw away Talents for money when she doesn’t need them anymore. That’s fine but not super useful, i would think that i’d plan on keeping my Talents around. You can play a talent for 1 cheaper, then chuck it for its full price, netting you a resource. But that’s just “Jenny with extra steps”, which is an awkward position to be in when you are a Jenny yourself.
Signature and Weakness: Without the steady extra income that her canon version has, the Twin Pistols are a bit out of place. At the same time, her new abilities don’t help her a lot with mitigating her notoriously awful weakness.
Card access: This is where Parallel Jenny gets most of her juice. There are some neat Talents outside of Rogue available. Some of them help with movement, like Safeguard and Pathfinder. She might even go for some Scavenging. Most of them do of course hand out skill boosts of all kinds and the tri-class Talents allow her to specialize in whatever trait she wants. Is all of that better than level 0 of all classes? I’d call it about equal. Some real power available here, but more boxed into her specific gimmick.

The thing i will say about parallel Jenny is that she at least doesn’t get obsoleted by the many other investigators that also gain money as their gimmick. And if you really find a reason to go all in on that Talent trait, then her investigator ability does give you some decent returns. For that, i feel comfortable in raising her in rank into B on both sides. I still don’t find her particularly powerful or exciting, Talent as a trait is riddled with redundancies (many cards that effectively do the same thing, so getting access to all of them doesn’t matter too much) and lack of internal synergy so you don’t get much here that really rewards you in a way that stands out.

Parallel Mateo: A // C
Statline and Soak: Same as the real version’s. Typical Mystic soak, but a rather flat spread of stats. He is more capable of making this work than his mainline version thanks to being able to count on the +2 from blesses.
Investigator ability: He can use investigators at his location, including himself of course, as batteries for Bless tokens and conjure those at will back from them. That makes any sort of bless interaction from assets or events incredibly consistent, almost completely removing the random element out of it. This is very strong of course. Even at a worst case, the innate +2 of a bless token can bolster his tests and let him succeed at a staggering amount of things that would leave regular Mateo scrambling for answers. In exchange for having a proper investigator ability now, he gives up that build-around of an Elder Sign, but that’s a very good trade.
Signature and Weakness: These both care about sealing the Elder Sign, something that Parallel Mateo cares a lot less about than regular one. This simultanously makes his signature easier to play and his weakness even less relevant. I don’t think either really matters much in the big picture, though.
Card access: Clips off the top end of Mystic, but gives him the unrestricted access to Bless he should have had from the start. A much better card pool, but you do pay for it by losing out on the 5XP headstart that Mateo gets in the sacred timeline.

Getting to run all Blessed cards and getting to profit off of their triggers with near-perfect consistency is incredibly powerful. Most notably, the red Covenant is pretty much broken by him and lets him just pass tests at will and actually works his flat statline in his favor. Other investigators get to do similar things, but Parallel Mateo does it by combining an investigator ability with a low XP permanent. So it’s online from turn 1, action 1, no setup required aside from tossing a bless into the bag. Doesn’t even need to be a lot of them, just one is enough because the ability does even return that bless to the bag. I’ve not played him myself yet, but i’d put him into high A, possibly low A+ for power. Do i see him on a tier with Luke and Agnes? Eeeeh. Let’s got with an A for now. I also feel like even if he were to get A+, that’d be mostly a ranking for the Covenant and not actually for the investigator.
On the enjoyment side, there’s not much here for me to care about if i am honest. He’s a Bless investigator. And while there’s nothing wrong with that, there’s like a dozen of those now. I’m over it. C.

Marion Tavares: A // S
Statline and Soak: Very flat stats. Notably the first non-Carson Guardian with bad willpower, which is a dangerous combination with her 6 sanity. We are in Skids territory here.
Investigator ability: Very good. The potential payoff of a card and an action every turn is fantastic and well worth losing a handslot for. It requires building your deck a certain way, but that’s something we can handle.
Signature: Her two skill cards do help with her flat stats a lot. These are quite good, i think.
Weakness: This eats up a lot of draws when you get rid of it. This is a scary weakness that you can not ignore because that horror is going to eat you up otherwise. Thankfully her ability generates so much momentum that this should be fine to just take on the chin. Drawing it very early could be an issue because it could just make you fizzle out on the crucial first turns and prevent you from gaining the momentum you’d need to just plow past it later on.
Card access: Bit of a weird one. Guardian 0-5 plus a choice of either Improvised, Fortune or Gambit 0-2. And Survivor level 0. Notably that Survivor access is not restricted to Events and Skills as it so often is on other investigators. That all sounds good to me, each of the traits has some spicy stuff to add to the mix.

She’s Winifred for events. How can i not absolutely adore this investigator? I’ll just throw that S for enjoyment up there without further justification beyond that. On the power side, she doesn’t remotely reach Winifred of course. She’s still doing ultimately very fair things, but she does it while picking up a lot of raw value from her investigator ability. She’ll be able to put out some high impact turns and won’t even need a whole lot of time to reload for the next one. I see her as a low A for now, but i could see her move up if it turns out that she can indeed get that bonus every turn. An A+ is not impossible in the future, but let’s approach this more cautiously and not get tangled up in hype and hope.

Lucius Galloway: A // B+
Statline and Soak: His statline is very optimized towards both of his classes. His 8/6 distribution for health and sanity is a bit unusual. Like Marion, he is 2 willpower with 6 sanity which needs some attention.
Investigator ability: Not bad, not great. Sort of like Roland, except that Lucius likely has an easier time picking up that clue without the ability anyways. Not really much to write home about, but a few extra clues never hurt anyone of course.
Signature: This thing is really good, right? Getting +1 to a test each turn (provided you find a clue each turn, which is not a huge barrier) is great and if you manage to turn a fail by 1 into a success by 0 this way, you even get to draw a card. Takes no slot either. Just a really good card that also interacts with a couple Seeker and Rogue archetypes.
Weakness: We already established horror as a potential weakpoint for Lucius and this applies additional pressure in exactly that spot. You probably don’t want to just stop discovering clues, so you will need to find a way to heal or soak. Even then, this reshuffles to eat further draws. Yuck.
Card access: Seeker with subclass Rogue is obviously a strong combination. There are some that are stronger, but there’s no doubt that Lucius can build some disgustingly powerful stuff from that pool.

A rather generic package overall, which should make it easy-ish to find references in the existing pool of investigators to give Lucius a first appraisal. I already compared his investigator ability to Roland’s. But the first thing that crosses my mind here is how he compares to his Rogue-seeker counterpart, Trish. She plays a very similar clue/evasion game with a similar card pool, after all. I don’t think Lucius reaches Trish. Her automatic successes from her investigator ability that can be channeled into either clues or evades are just on a different level than Lucius’ more limited “when you oversucceed” clue. Five agility and a cool signature do make a difference, but not enough to catch up to her in that department. I think I’ll put him in A for now, together with Finn and the cheese man.
For enjoyment… i don’t know. B? Maybe B+ thanks to his card pool? Let’s go with B+, that’s where Trish is as well and that seems about right to me. Ultimately he seems very redundant to me, so I am prepared to rank him down next year.

Agatha Crane (both versions): A // A
Statline and Soak: A good and open-ended statline, as long as you can make use of the options unlocked by them. Worst case, she has good Intellect paired with good encounter protection.
Investigator ability: Like Marion, she gets the equivalent of an action and a card when her ability triggers. It’s a good deal harder to trigger however and comes with additional timing restrictions, so it’s overall a notch or two weaker. Still, the raw value is there, you just need to commit to collect on it.
Signature: Phenomenal enabler for her ability and also a great tool just to pass tests. This is a premium signature asset that you will want to dig out of your deck.
Weakness: A weakness that shuffles back, eats up draws and actions and makes your tests worse. This is rather horrid and provides a counter-balance to the signature.
Card access (Seeker): Not bad at all. Daisy’s pool is better, but Agatha is better set up to actually use the mystic cards she can take. Insight 0-3 is not a huge pool of out-of-class events, but there are some real gems in there that do matter. Like with Daniela, there is a lot of “What if” whinging around her deckbuilding and how it could be “better”, but like with Daniela that seems largely unjustified to me.
Card access (Mystic): Probably a bit better than the Seeker version. While the Spells trait doesn’t yield a lot of particularly great options out of the Mystic class, the Seeker level 0 is notoriously stacked with fantastic cards. More importantly, the Mystic main class has some really good options for Agatha to get her investigator ability to fire.

Like Marion, i see Agatha as an A for power initially. A lot of how that shakes out with either investigator is going to depend on how reliably that ability is going to trigger. For that reason, i am trending upwards with Marion (high A, possibly A+) while i am more sceptical of Agatha and could see her trend downwards (low A, possibly B+). Especially her Seeker side has to rely heavily on her signature to get the necessary trigger each turn to cash in on her promise. It’s always possible that Drowned City serves us another great Seeker enabler for her, but all we got so far is the Researched card. And while that one is solid, it’s a one-off so hardly reliable.
I am looking forward to trying her out. Event based play is a favorite of mine and getting her ability to pop off is a neat challenge. She also directs me to play some cards that i usually wouldn’t include, so that’s a plus. I’ll call that an A as well.

Michael McGlen: A+ // B+
Statline and Soak: Very optimized statline for a fighter. 5 combat and both defensive stats at 3 makes McGlen as resilient against the encounter deck as most survivors.
Investigator ability: That’s Jenny with extra steps, so not that great? A resource per turn is what Jenny gets and Michael has the condition of having to have an enemy to fight to get that resource. If he has multiple firearms out, he can get 2 resources (or, in magical christmas land, 3 or even 4 resources) but i’d weigh that against the dead turns where he gets nothing and just call this Jenny’s ability in total. Maybe slightly above it, depending on player (and thus enemy) count. Which is fiiiiine… The resources are key to getting your firearms out of course, so it’s a relevant ability for sure, even if the raw value is not quite up where we’ve come to expect it.
Signature: You can’t run Bandolier and the Quickdraw Holster is somewhat questionable in quality, so the signature jumps in to fulfill your dreams of holding four guns at the same time. It does void the accessory slot, so get those Relic Hunters ready if you also want piano wires or cigarette cases. But the signature does play well with the investigator ability for sure. The built-in Prepared for the Worst on playing the sig is also definitely relevant. So this should work out fine.
Weakness: Getting all your guns confiscated will randomly hose you in a similar way to Pete or Charlie when they have to exhaust all their stuff while in danger. Overall, this weakness seems fine, but a bit swingy. Sometimes you are staring down an enemy and taking attacks of opportunity to get a gun out again. Other times you are clapping excitedly because the police takes away your empty guns and shuffles full guns into your deck.
Card access: Very specialized. The ability to take all guns and gun related cards gives him all the firepower he could possibly need. This enables him to serve the specific fantasy behind his character very well, but at the same time puts him into a fairly constrained box. I would compare this to Nathaniel, who similarly does only one thing, but does that thing very well.

What did i give Nathaniel for power? A+? Do i see Michael in the same tier as him? They certainly share a lot of DNA in that they are both one-minded fighters with 5 combat, a card pool that gets them exactly what they want, a signature that tutors up what they need and a weakness that hoses them to a point. I suppose it’s as good a starting point as any. Let’s call it a low A+.
For his other rank, i am looking forward to playing the “one million tiny pistols” build with him that plays Derringers (both .18 and .41), Lugers and upgraded Bulldogs and gets more money for emptying those back than he spent for them initially. I am not super high on him because i don’t really expect any big surprises or new insights from playing him, but it should be a good time. B+, but a higher B+ than Lucius got.

George Barnaby: A+ // A+
Statline and Soak: I actually really like the flat statline here, Survivor can make that work very easily and George in particular strikes me as an investigator that wants to do multiple jobs at the same time.
Investigator ability: What initially looks like an ability that offers fair exchanges of a card for a card is really easy to unhinge with a plethora of cards from the Survivor pool. Anything that discards for value or as a cost immediately shoots up in playability when George holds them. And many of those cards are already good by themselves.
Signature: Depending on how you use the cards he has stored, the signature will fluctuate in value. I suspect that it will mostly end up being not all that great, at least not to the extent that you’d welcome having three of them in your deck. But there are some fun tricks to be had with it at least.
Weakness: Not as bad as it looks, but still plenty bad. Assuming you draw it during your upkeep, you will lose your hand, but get to put one of them under you straight away and also draw a replacement card. So it won’t leave you completely unable to do something. That being said, you do want to be able to recover from this, either by having cards to play from the discard or some sort of card draw that can kickstart you forwards again.
Card access: I like this new type of deckbuilding and could see it become something that gets used more often in the future. Full level 0 splash from two subclasses without limiting it to non-assets or something like that is pretty good and the limit of 10 cards is generous enough to do most shenanigans you are thinking of. George in particular has access to the level 0 cards of the second best and third best class in the game while being main in the best class… so that’s just an incredibly powerful pool overall.

This man draws so many cards in such a stacked card pool that i find it hard to imagine him being anything less than an A+ for power. He is very capable of using pretty much every Survivor archetype under the sun and his churn through the deck will make all of that very consistent.
This use of a second hand where he an store cards for later is very appealing to me. A skill-based deck that mostly ignores the signature and just plans on discarding cards that want to be committed anyways is likely the best approach to him, but i definitely want to experiment with building around the concept of a second hand that you can swap to with the signature as well. There is a lot of meat to the deckbuilding options, so George could end up becoming one of the Survivor investigators that i return to often. I am going with an A+ on that side.

12 Replies to “Updates to the Investigator Tierlists for 2025”

  1. Regarding Patrice, one way I thought of it is viewing her as a mini-Wini. Don’t be afraid to play assets, but also keep in mind that the cards in your hand are resources even if you can’t play them, provided you design your deck so you can commit them to as many types of tests as possible (i.e., even if she could take it, Fighting Lessons would probably be a no-go for Patrice).

    For Michael, I really, really want to like him, but the more I hear the community’s opinions, the more worried I get. I’m personally positive on his ability (he basically turns every gun into a Mauser), though I understand that I’m looking at it through rose-colored glasses (if he’s so great because he turns every gun into a once-per-turn Mauser, why not just take Tony and give him a Mauser?). I do think his weakness isn’t as debilitating as some (including myself in the past) think; Sleight of Hand, .25 Automatic, Lupara, and Fence plus an Illicit gun all provide Michael with a safety valve in case the dreaded Confiscation in upkeep + enemy in Mythos combination occurs without dragging down the deck’s performance by being completely useless if it never happens.

    1. If all you want to do is fight with a Mauser and poke guys with a knife, then Tony is going to be your man.

      But i don’t think that Michael actually tries to compete with Tony too much. He hits more into Leo’s niche of being able to use the big Guardian guns with a rogue card pool. Lots of things that were previously only possible in Leo (like builds around the BAR) can now also be done in Michael. And possibly better because Leo’s ally centric ability was never particularly helpful there while Michael’s extra econ is pretty great.

  2. This might be Patrice’s year in the same way Rita has benefitted from all the tricks and such. George’s desire to discard will work nicely for Patrice as well

    1. On the one hand, Patrice is going to benefit from a lot of things that are printed with Barnaby in mind.

      On the other hand, Barnaby is going to end up replacing Patrice in a bunch of survivor centric deck ideas. Luckily their deckbuilding is very different when it comes to the subclasses, so the overlap is at least minimized there.

      1. Yeah, I think this game is suffering from a heckton of power creep as it goes on, but the joy of it is that you can take the investigators that interest you and do fun things with them. I have zero interest in the lawyer, but I don’t mind a cheeky Patrice game so new tools for her are always welcome.

        I like problem solving weird and wonderful (and usually restrictive) decks so I find the Patrices and Lolas of the world far more interesting than the Rex and Lucius’s.

        And I cannot wait to try your idea for Lolafred Haybbamock! I share your love for that investigator!

  3. I felt the same way about Jim until I ran him in one of our Hard/Expert campaign play-throughs. I’d never ran him and wanted to check off that box. I think this was our HM Scarlett Keys run. Slip a Nkosi into Jim’s deck and turn half the chaos bag into +0? Insane. Maybe not very interesting, but definitely powerful. I honestly think he’s a top contender in Hard/Expert because he gets so many more outs for whichever skill tests can’t be avoided. But I agree he’s kinda pointless in normal.

    I’m also a little surprised by the Silas Marsh ranking. That man responsible for breaking the game with not just one, but two different decks, and getting some key cards taboo’d (Eucatastrophe and A Watchful Peace.) It seems like design will always need to watch this guy unless they unleash the kraken again.

    100% agree with Wini being S+ … so much fun. I need to run Wini again, soon. Thank you for these rankings! I follow your blog regularly and we’re playing your Return to Innsmouth right now.

    1. Aye, i heard about Jim performing better in Hard/Expert and i can definitely get behind that. It’s not my frame of reference though, similar to investigators that really pop off in Solo.

      I am not terribly interested in abuse cases, i usually assume that one engages the game in good faith and not with the intent of just breaking it. Otherwise more than half of the investigators would just be S ranked, the card pool is riddled with abuse cases. I feel like Silas falls off a lot once you factor those out. I will definitely acknowledge that my line for what qualifies as an abuse case can be very shifting. For whatever reason i am much more forgiving of William endlessly recycling something than of Silas.

      Have fun on the Return to Innsmouth. Don’t be afraid of having someone grow gills, the Return is somewhat built around the assumption ;)

  4. I’ve been reading your content for years and wanna say first of all you’re doing a great job, really like your rankings and decks.

    I also tend to gravitate towards the same style of decks you seem to enjoy: fast, combo-heavy decks almost always involving green cards. I’ve probably played more variants of Sefina than every other investigator I’ve played combined.

    If you made it this far you’ve reached the point of this post/comment: I think you really ought to give parallel Wendy another chance. I 100% agree the tidal memento is confusing and stupid, and I did try it and decide it’s not worth the table space. However I continually end up going back to regular front/parallel back Wendy. She’s like survivor Kohaku. Curse spell suite works great with 4 will and all the survivor boosts (moonstone, ice pick, granny/Peter, etc). There’s just so many cool decks you can make with blurse access and the survivor core is only getting better with time.

    1. I think i am at a point where there are simply enough investigators around that i don’t fret if a handful of them don’t click for me, so i can’t say that i am too optimistic about a Para-Wendy comeback story :D Especially when it comes to Bless and Curse we do actually have a surprising number of investigators tailored to using those cards (i am counting people like Tommy and Dexter among them) so i don’t feel like i am particularly missing out either.

      I definitely hear you on how attractive Survivor access is, i’ve actually been thinking that Survivor is stronger than Seeker for a while. It’s the best class at level 0-2 imo.

  5. I know I am a bit late to the party here, but what cards in particular make a post Hemlock Skids so much better? Is this all a prank hahahaha?

Leave a Reply